Sipadan Hostage News at e-Borneo.com

Sipadan/Pandanan Hostage Crisis

Sponsor Highlight

e-Borneo's Main PageBorneo NewsBorneo DirectoryTravel Borneo


19 September 2000 - ABS-CBN

Germany, France protest RP military offensive

MANILA, (ABS-CBN) - Germany joined France on Monday in protest the Philippine government's decision to attack the Abu Sayyaf group in Sulu which is still holding on to 19 hostages, including two French journalists.

The German government said it shares "the anxiety of our friends and partners in France on the matter of the military operations in Jolo."

"The federal government calls upon the Philippine government to ensure the safe release of the remaining hostages," the diplomatic note stated.

Three Germans were among the original batch of hostages seized from a diving resort in Sipadan four months ago. They were freed after Abu Sayyaf rebels were paid some $1.5 million in ransom.

The other day, French President Jacques Chirac expressed his "concern and disagreement " to President Estrada's decision Saturday to free the remaining hostages by way of a military offensive.

But Malacañang officials said on Monday the Estrada administration had nothing to explain to the French leader, who also demanded that the Philippines justify the assault.

"All we can say to our friends in France is that they should understand our situation. This is a matter where national interest must take precedence," Press Secretary Ricardo Puno said.

Puno assured the French government that the Philippines will do everything it can to rescue all the hostages although "the Armed Forces and the Philippine National Police will have to do what they have to do." He said the President has given more than enough time for the peaceful resolution of the hostage crisis.

Palace officials pointed out that European governments with citizens being held by the Abu Sayyaf had previously pressured the Philippines not to take action against the rebels, which only emboldened the kidnappers to seize more captives.

"We tried to end the crisis through negotiations, but that option is no longer possible. We must put an end to this now or face the prospect of more kidnappings," he said.

Prioritize safety

Meanwhile, the French foreign ministry reminded Philippine authorities on Monday that the safety of hostages still held by the Abu Sayyaf must remain a top priority.

"We are in constant contact with political and military authorities in the Philippines, with whom we do not stop insisting that the hostages' safety must remain a priority," the ministry said in a statement.

President Chirac also expressed his concern for the two French hostages held in Jolo, saying that he took the matter "very seriously".


In a phone conversation on Sunday, Chirac told his country's ambassador to the Philippines, Gillers Chouraqui, that the safety of the two French hostages was "an absolute priority to France."

Chouraqui met with Acting Philippine Foreign Affairs Secretary Franklin Ebdalin, who replied that the decision on the assault was made after "all avenues of negotiations had been exhausted."

'There is no other way but to take action at this time, " Ebdalin said.

Antonio Modena, Philippine charge' d affaires in Paris, has likewise been summoned by the French foreign ministry to formally file a protest .

A French foreign ministry crisis team met early Sunday but was unable to give any further information about the fate of the hostages since the military operation began.

"We are also in contact with US authorities, and we are asking them to relay our hopes and fears for our two compatriots," the statement said.

The other day, Philippine authorities claimed the two French journalists, Jean Jacques Le Garrec and Roland Madura , are no longer in the camp which the Army raided.

Diplomatic protest

Senate leaders warned on Monday that the Philippine government may consider filing a diplomatic protest if Chirac continues to intervene in the internal affairs of the country, particularly the way the government is handling the hostage crisis in Mindanao.

Senate President Franklin Drilon and Majority Leader Francisco Tatad made the warning even as they defended the decision taken by President Estrada to mount a military assault against the Abu Sayyaf Group.

"I will support the diplomatic protest if they continue to interfere with our domestic decisions. We need to run these military operations to the best that our national interest would require," he added.

Tatad expressed disappointment over the pronouncements issued by Chirac.

"I hope the French government will remember that on Feb. 3, 1976 when members of the Somali Coast Liberation Front hijacked a school bus containing 30 school children in Djibouti , the government in Paris decided to dispatched its counter-terrorist unit to undertake a rescue operation, even while negotiations were going on. At least one schoolgirl was killed in that operation but the unit succeeded in rescuing 29 children," he recalled.


Dangerous assault

Reacting to the military offensive, three ex-Jolo hostages said the Philippine Army posed a more immediate danger to the 22 remaining hostages than the rebels, and demanded an end to the assault.

The ex-hostages , Stephane Loisy and Sonia Wendling , from France, and Risto Vahanen from Finland, said the remaining hostages had more to fear from the rescuers than from their captors.

"We haven't succumbed to Stockholm syndrome, but we know very well who could help us," Wendling's companion, Stephane Loisy said. "Our captors were our best security."

Recalling that they had been "very , very well treated " by the rebels, Loisy said it wasn't " in the captors interests to harm the hostages," adding: "We never felt they would kill us in cold blood."

For Risto Vahanen, "an attack (by government troops) was what we feared most."

"Without seeing us, (the Philippine Army) showered us with mortars - with a small difference in aim, we wouldn't be here today," Loisy said.

Back to Sipadan/Pandanan Hostages News

Back to This Week's Borneo News


Info Sections -

Info Borneo Inside Borneo Inside Internet
Premier Services - Borneo Forum Classified Ads Online Chat Event Board Free Email Web Hosting
Electronic Cards Borneo Auction Borneo Quiz
E-Borneo Project - General Info Contribution Feedback Submit URL Mailing List Link to Us

Home  |  About e-Borneo  |  Announcement  |  Services  |  Bookmark Us  |  Disclaimer  |  Privacy Policy  |  Copyright  |  Contact

Copyright © 1999, 2000   e-Borneo.  All rights reserved worldwide